Data Centers Are Coming: National Priority, Local Sacrifice?
If AI is a national priority, so are the data centers it runs on. And every one of them lands in somebody’s town.
If AI is a national priority, so are the data centers it runs on. And every one of them lands in somebody’s town. Who decides, and who pays?
In Sterling, Virginia, backup diesel generators ran all night next to people’s homes. In Louisiana, officials signed at least 54 secret NDAs on data center and other industrial deals, and one small town only learned about a $3.6 billion project when it was nearly done. Nationally, about 342 gigawatts of data centers have been announced, but only about 50 are running. And last week voters weighed in, from the Texas governor’s race to local limits on data centers around the country.
The starting point: a conversation on @smerconish’s show between developer Brian O’Neill and Abre’ Conner of the @NAACP, who both made strong cases and didn’t agree.
In this episode I look at:
Why so many towns feel railroaded: secrecy, deals that come in pieces, no time to think, and officials who may not speak for the whole community What a town really gets (jobs, property taxes) and what it gives up (noise, water, power bills, tax breaks that mostly don’t pay off) What happens if the AI boom doesn’t pan out, and who’s left holding the bill Why local democracy is necessary but not enough on its own What informed consent looks like in practice: Texas energy polls, the Penobscot River dams, and nuclear waste siting in Finland and Canada
I end with four non-negotiables every big data center should have to meet, the Four No’s: No secret deals. No rubber stamps. No hidden subsidies. No walking away. Plus five questions to ask if a data center is coming to your town.
IMO a big build-out is coming either way. What’s not inevitable is where it goes, on what terms, and who carries the risk. Right now communities are carrying too much of it. That has to flip.
CHAPTERS 00:00 Cold open: who decides, and who pays? 03:00 Why do so many towns feel railroaded? 09:00 What does a town get, and what does it give up? 13:30 What if the AI boom doesn’t pan out? 15:30 Can a few officials decide this for everyone? 18:30 Can a data center ever be right for a community? 22:00 The Four No’s 24:30 My unpopular view 26:30 Five questions to ask, and close
Read episode pageSource episode