PEPFAR: Worth the Cost? | John Donnelly on Lifeline (Part 2 of 2)
PEPFAR is credited with saving about 26 million lives. That represents a huge success at face value.
PEPFAR is credited with saving about 26 million lives. That represents a huge success at face value.
In Part 2 of my conversation with John Donnelly, author of Lifeline: The Story of PEPFAR, the Greatest Humanitarian Initiative of Our Time, we ask what that cost, and what it left behind.
We talk about how big PEPFAR got (in Kenya, most of the US embassy's budget), the warnings from CDC reviewers in 2002 that the program would build parallel systems nobody could take over, the opportunity cost of $120 billion when pneumonia and diarrhea were killing more children, Senator DeMint's "mission creep" charge, and how a program with no real constituency at home or ownership abroad was frozen almost overnight in 2025.
And the question a lot of Americans are asking: with this much national debt, can we afford it? IMO the answer is more interesting than yes or no.
Lifeline is out Tuesday, October 13, from HarperCollins Publishers. Pre-order: https://bit.ly/3TkTjNV Missed Part 1? https://youtu.be/TV-ajC8k8SM
Read episode pageSource episode