Episode 27

Data Centers Are Coming: National Priority, Local Sacrifice?

Open source episode

If AI is a national priority, so are the data centers it runs on. And every one of them lands in somebody’s town. Who decides, and who pays?

In Sterling, Virginia, backup diesel generators ran all night next to people’s homes. In Louisiana, officials signed at least 54 secret NDAs on data center and other industrial deals, and one small town only learned about a $3.6 billion project when it was nearly done. Nationally, about 342 gigawatts of data centers have been announced, but only about 50 are running. And last week voters weighed in, from the Texas governor’s race to local limits on data centers around the country.

The starting point: a conversation on @smerconish’s show between developer Brian O’Neill and Abre’ Conner of the @NAACP, who both made strong cases and didn’t agree.

In this episode I look at:

Why so many towns feel railroaded: secrecy, deals that come in pieces, no time to think, and officials who may not speak for the whole community What a town really gets (jobs, property taxes) and what it gives up (noise, water, power bills, tax breaks that mostly don’t pay off) What happens if the AI boom doesn’t pan out, and who’s left holding the bill Why local democracy is necessary but not enough on its own What informed consent looks like in practice: Texas energy polls, the Penobscot River dams, and nuclear waste siting in Finland and Canada

I end with four non-negotiables every big data center should have to meet, the Four No’s: No secret deals. No rubber stamps. No hidden subsidies. No walking away. Plus five questions to ask if a data center is coming to your town.

IMO a big build-out is coming either way. What’s not inevitable is where it goes, on what terms, and who carries the risk. Right now communities are carrying too much of it. That has to flip.

CHAPTERS 00:00 Cold open: who decides, and who pays? 03:00 Why do so many towns feel railroaded? 09:00 What does a town get, and what does it give up? 13:30 What if the AI boom doesn’t pan out? 15:30 Can a few officials decide this for everyone? 18:30 Can a data center ever be right for a community? 22:00 The Four No’s 24:30 My unpopular view 26:30 Five questions to ask, and close

Episode 2400:47:12

Soft Power: America's Misunderstood Investment | Dr. Samantha Nutt, War Child

Is foreign aid charity — or one of the cheapest instruments of power a country has? Dr.

Is foreign aid charity — or one of the cheapest instruments of power a country has?

Dr. Samantha Nutt, physician and founder of War Child, has spent thirty years working in Somalia, Sudan, eastern Congo, Afghanistan and Iraq. Michael Brown has spent fifty on land and natural resource governance in many of the same places. In this conversation they take on the questions the aid debate usually avoids:

— Should NGOs be working themselves out of a job — and why is it still so rarely national staff running them? — Being at the table isn't enough. Why local communities need leverage, and what happens to their voice without it — Is civil society making progress anywhere at war? — The resource curse, and whether the US–China competition over Congo's minerals changes anything for Congolese people — Aid as soft and hard power: something to fight, or something to accept? — Why gutting USAID isn't charity withdrawn — and what it has to do with the next pandemic — Can the current cynicism about foreign aid be overcome — and what's actually in everyone's best interest?

The Unpopular View challenges assumptions and takes positions many in the aid and development world don't like. Host Michael Brown is the author of Redeeming REDD+ and Climate Mitigation in the Land Sector of the Global South.

Dr. Samantha Nutt is the author of Damned Nations: Greed, Guns, Armies, and Aid.

Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@UCW4HD_vP6WXjZPn7_qcTXeQ

Website/All epsidoes: https://theunpopularview.com/

Read episode pageSource episode
Episode 2300:40:58

Gen Z European: Europe Talks Tough on Russia — Until It's Inconvenient

Europe talks tough on Russia — but how consistent is it actually? Armin Sumansky, a Gen Z Czech student at Bates College, turns the usual question around in Part 2 of our conversation: where Europe's line on Russia goes soft when it's inconvenient, where European consensus on...

Europe talks tough on Russia — but how consistent is it actually?

Armin Sumansky, a Gen Z Czech student at Bates College, turns the usual question around in Part 2 of our conversation: where Europe's line on Russia goes soft when it's inconvenient, where European consensus on migration is really heading, whether American power makes the world safer or more dangerous, what Europe and the US should actually do about Ukraine, and whether his generation's views travel beyond college-educated peers.

This is Part 2 of our conversation with Armin, a second-year student at Bates College triple-majoring in Economics, Politics, and European Studies, heading to the London School of Economics next year.

Part 1 covered Gen Z framing, why he chose an American college, and how his family's history under Soviet-bloc Czechoslovakia shapes his read on Russia.

Watch Part 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0IxoT5YY__c&t=804s

Topics in this segment: 0:00 Cold open — Ceuta and Europe's migration contradiction – Where European consensus on migration is actually heading – Is Europe's Russia policy as principled as it claims? – Does American power reduce conflict or cause it? – What should Europe — and the US — actually do about Ukraine? – Is there a real US/Europe Gen Z perception gap? – Armin's new political journal and his plans at LSE

The Unpopular View gives credentialed people a platform to make the case for views that are popular with some and unpopular with others. This episode steps outside the usual development-policy lane to hear directly from a Gen Z European.

Subscribe for more conversations that don't fit either side's script: https://www.youtube.com/@UCW4HD_vP6WXjZPn7_qcTXeQ

All Unpopular View Episodes: https://theunpopularview.com/

Read episode pageSource episode
Episode 2100:21:20

USAID Is Gone. What Should Replace It? | Emily Brearley (3/3)

USAID has been dismantled. The World Bank's own evaluations keep finding what its projects don't achieve.

USAID has been dismantled. The World Bank's own evaluations keep finding what its projects don't achieve. So the question is no longer whether the aid architecture is broken — it's whether anything should replace it.

In the final segment of my three-part conversation with Dr. Emily Brearley — development economist, 25 years at the World Bank and other international institutions, and author of Aid Inferno: How to Reduce Poverty, Combat Global Warming, and Be a Good Person — we each put a blueprint on the table.

We agree on some fundamental issues and disagree on some important details.

Emily's answer is what she calls Solution 42: sharply narrow what institutions like the World Bank attempt. Stick to the sectors they demonstrably do well. Build in transparency and citizen involvement in project selection and evaluation. Fund a small number of high-impact projects chosen by people in recipient countries themselves. It rhymes with Esther Duflo's evidence-first approach.

We also agree that a social contract is a fundamental missing piece — clear goals, trade-offs and obligations that people on the ground can actually hold institutions to that are negotiated. In 40+ years of fieldwork I never saw one written, and neither USAID nor the World Bank has ever framed a project in those terms. Emily agrees that's a major gap.

Where we diverge somewhat is on who does the work. Should nationals do everything, or is there a place for foreigners with unique capacity building contributions to make?

ABOUT THE GUEST Dr. Emily Brearley is a development economist and former World Bank economist with ~25 years across the World Bank and other international institutions, leading programs in Africa, Latin America and Asia. Aid Inferno is a case-study-driven critique built on World Bank evaluation data arguing that development finance rewards spending and institutional survival over outcomes and accountability.

ABOUT THE SHOW The Unpopular View is for the exhausted middle — evidence over outrage, and criticism that doesn't spare either orthodoxy. Hosted by Michael Brown, international development consultant and author of Redeeming REDD (Routledge, 2013) and Climate Mitigation in the Land Sector of the Global South (Routledge, 2026).

🔔 Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@TheUnpopularView_MichaelBrown

All episodes: https://theunpopularview.com/episodes

Read episode pageSource episode
Data Centers Are Coming: National Priority, Local Sacrifice? | The Unpopular View | The Unpopular View